Ice Cream Cakes & Pies

Kelley Country Creamery offers a wide variety of ice cream cakes to meet all your birthday, anniversary, graduation, baptism, confirmation or any other special occasion needs. We have the traditional half Whitewash Vanilla/half Udderly Comforting Chocolate with chocolate cake crunch and fudge available in our reach-in freezer daily. Custom cakes are also available, create your own cake by choosing two of our 300+ ice cream flavors and a filling. (48 Hour notice if flavors are available)

ALL CAKE ORDERS FOR WEEKEND PICKUP (SATURDAY AND SUNDAY) MUST BE ORDERED BY THURSDAY AT NOON.

**Please call to place cake order (920-923-1715), we do not take emails for cakes orders.

Ice Cream Cake Sizes and Prices

7 in. Round
(feeds 8-10ppl)

Traditional Price:
7in. – $35.99+tax

Custom Price:
7in. – $38.99+tax

9 in. Round
(feeds 10-12ppl)

Traditional Price:
9in. – $39.99+tax

Custom Price:
9in. – $42.99+tax

9×13 (¼ sheet)
(feeds 12-20ppl)

Traditional Price:
9×13 – $49.99+tax

Custom Price:
9×13 – $52.99+tax

Ice Cream Pie
(feeds 6-8ppl)

• Choose one ice cream flavor
• Oreo or Graham cracker crust

Price:
Pie – $23.99+tax

WHAT IS A TRADITIONAL ICE CREAM CAKE?

Top Layer: Whitewash Vanilla Ice Cream
Filling: Fudge & Chocolate Cake Crunch
Bottom Layer: Udderly Comforting Chocolate

WHAT IS A CUSTOM ICE CREAM CAKE?

Top Layer: Your Choice of Ice Cream Flavor
Filling: Your Choice of Filling
Bottom Layer: Your Choice of Ice Cream Flavor

WHERE DO YOU CHOOSE YOUR FLAVORS FOR CUSTOM CAKES AND ICE CREAM PIES?

Visit Our Ice Cream Flavors Tab and Choose from over 300+ Flavors.
Get Creative — the Options are Endless!!

FILLING OPTIONS:

Hot Fudge, Caramel, Strawberry, Raspberry, Graham Cracker, Chocolate Cookie Crunch, Candy Bars, etc.

SOME OF KELLEY’S FAVORITE ICE CREATE CAKE COMBINATIONS:

- Butter Pecan Ice Cream/Whitewash Vanilla Ice Cream with a pecan and caramel filling
- Udderly Comforting Chocolate/Strawberry Ice Cream with a strawberry and chocolate filling
- Strawberry Cheesecake/Blueberry Cheesecake with a Graham cracker filling
- Holstein Ice Cream (cookies and cream)/Karen’s Crazy Cake with a Twix candy bar filling (WOW!)