Ice Cream Flavors

The Kelley Country Creamery offers a large selection of our premium farmstead ice cream with 22 flavors available daily. Seasonal, specialty and brand new flavors are added frequently so call or stop by to see what’s new.

ice cream flavors

Acai Blueberry-Acai blueberry ice cream (summer seasonal)

Amie’s Amaretto – Amaretto ice cream with chocolate flakes and Maraschino cherries

Apple Raisin Strudel-Vanilla ice cream with raisins, apples and graham cracker crunch (fall seasonal)

Apple Turnover-Vanilla ice cream with apple turnovers and an apple swirl

Apricot-Apricot Ice Cream (summer seasonal)

Baby Sunny Apple- Vanilla Ice Cream with snickers, Sunflower Seeds and Apples

Banana-Banana ice cream

Banana Cream Pie- Banana Ice Cream with a Marshmallow Swirl and graham Crust Pieces

Bananas Foster-Vanilla Banana ice cream with bananas, caramel, cinnamon and a hint of rum

Banana Nut French Toast- French Toast Ice Cream with Banana pieces, Pecans and a Caramel Swirl

Banana Walnut-Banana ice cream with walnut pieces

Barnyard Bash- Maple Walnut ice cream with pieces of pancakes, waffles, French toast, and walnuts.

Bear Claw- Chocolate ice cream with Caramel and Cashews

Betsy’s Blueberry – Blueberry ice cream with blueberry bits

Black and Tan-Dark Chocolate and Coffee Ice Cream swirled

Black Angus- Chocolate ice cream with Oreos

Blackberry Pie-Blackberry Ice cream with Vanilla cake crunch and pie pieces

Black Cherry –Black Cherry ice cream with bordeaux cherries

Black Cherry Vanilla-Vanilla ice cream with bordeaux cherries

Black Forest- Chocolate ice cream with Brownies and Bordeaux Cherries

Black Licorice-Black licorice ice cream with black licorice pieces

Black Raspberry – Black raspberry ice cream

Black Raspberry Cheesecake- Cheesecake Ice cream with a Black Raspberry and Graham Cracker Swirl

Black Walnut-Vanilla ice cream with black walnuts

Bleu Cheese Pear- Pear ice cream with caramelized pears and Sartori blue cheese crumbles

Blonde Brownie- Blonde Brownie Ice Cream with white chocolate chips and walnuts

Blood Orange- Blood Orange ice cream (summer seasonal)

Blueberry Almond- Blueberry Ice Cream with Sliced Almonds

Blueberry Cheesecake – Cheesecake ice cream with blueberry and graham cracker swirl

Blueberry Delight-White cake batter ice cream with blueberries and vanilla cake crunch

Blueberry Turnover- Vanilla ice cream with blueberry turnovers and a blueberry swirl

Blue Velvet:  Blue Velvet Ice Cream with Blue Velvet Cake Pieces and a Cream Cheese Swirl

Boysenberry- Boysenberry ice cream (summer seasonal)

Brown Swiss- Chocolate malt ice cream with whoppers

Brownie Batter- Brownie Batter ice cream with brownie pieces and a chocolate swirl

Butter Brittle – Butter and brown sugar ice cream with toffee pieces

Butterscotch – Butterscotch ice cream

Butterscotch Coconut Crunch- Butterscotch ice cream with coconut crunch

Butter-Finger Pecan- Vanilla Ice Cream with Butterfinger and Pecans

Cake Batter-Yellow cake batter ice cream

Candy Bar – Chocolate ice cream with Heath, Butterfinger, Snickers, M&M, and Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Candy Cane Lane-White Mint Ice Cream with chocolate flakes and Crushed candy cane pieces (winter seasonal)

Cantaloupe-Cantaloupe ice cream (summer seasonal)

Caramel Apple Cheesecake- Cheesecake Ice Cream with Spiced Apples, Caramel, and Graham Cracker Pieces (fall seasonal)

Caramel Apple Pie- Cinnamon ice cream with spiced apples, graham cracker swirl and a caramel swirl (fall seasonal)

Caramel/Caramel Swirl-Caramel ice cream with a caramel swirl

Caramel Cookie Crunch-Vanilla ice cream with Twix candy bar pieces, vanilla cake crunch and a caramel swirl

Caramel Pretzel Cluster- Carmel ice cream with chocolate covered pretzels and caramel swirl

Carrot Cake- Carrot cake ice cream with carrot cake pieces, cream cheese frosting and walnuts

ChaCha- Rum Chata Ice Cream

Chai Tea- Chai Tea ice cream

Champagne- Champagne Ice Cream

Cherry Cheesecake- Cheesecake ice cream with Cherry and Graham cracker swirl

Cherry Licorice- Cherry licorice ice cream with cherry licorice pieces

Cherry Pie A La Mode- Vanilla Ice Cream with Cherry Pie Filling and Pie Pieces

Cherry Vanilla-Vanilla ice cream with maraschino cherry halves

Cheesecake with Oreos- Cheesecake Ice Cream with Oreos

Cheesecake with Snickers- Cheesecake Ice Cream with Snickers

Chew Your Cud – Bubble gum ice cream with bubble gum pieces

Chocolate Almond-Chocolate Ice cream with Roasted and Diced Almonds

Chocolate Andes- Chocolate ice cream with Andes candy pieces (winter seasonal)

Chocolate Baby Ruth- Chocolate Ice Cream with Baby Ruth pieces

Chocolate Butterfinger- Chocolate ice cream with Butterfinger candy bar pieces

Chocolate Caramel Cup- Chocolate Ice Cream with Caramel Cups and a Caramel Swirl

Chocolate Caramel Crunch-Chocolate ice cream with Nestle Crunch bar pieces and a caramel swirl

Chocolate Caramel Swirl- Chocolate Caramel Swirl

Chocolate Cheesecake w/Raspberry –Chocolate Cheesecake ice cream with a Raspberry Swirl

Chocolate Chip Cheesecake-Cheesecake Ice Cream with Chocolate Flakes

Chocolate Chocolate Chip -Chocolate ice cream with chocolate flakes

Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cookie- Chocolate Cookie Dough Ice Cream with Cookie Dough and Chocolate Flakes

Chocolate Covered Banana- Chocolate Ice Cream with a Chocolate Syrup Swirl, Chopped nuts and banana pieces

Chocolate Covered Oranges- Dreamsicle Ice Cream with a Fudge Swirl

Chocolate Covered Potato Chip- Caramel ice cream with caramel swirl and chocolate covered potato chips

Chocolate Covered Strawberry- Chocolate ice cream with strawberries

Chocolate Fudge Ripple-Chocolate Ice Cream with a Fudge Ripple

Chocolate Hazelnut- Chocolate Hazelnut ice cream with Hazelnuts

Chocolate Heath – Chocolate ice cream with Heath candy bar pieces

Chocolate M & M – Chocolate ice cream with M & M pieces

Chocolate Malt – Chocolate malt ice cream

Chocolate Peanut Butter cup-Chocolate Ice Cream with a peanut butter cup

Chocolate Peanut Butter swirl – Chocolate ice cream with peanut butter swirl

Chocolate Snickers – Chocolate ice cream with Snickers candy bar pieces

Christmas Pudding- Rum flavored ice cream with dried fruit and walnuts (winter seasonal)

Cinnamon – Cinnamon ice cream

Cinnamon Chocolate Chip-Cinnamon ice cream with chocolate flakes

Clark’s Calf Crunch – Vanilla ice cream with caramel and fudge swirls and peanuts

Coconut Caramel Daisy- Vanilla Ice Cream with Girl Scout Samoa Cookies and a Chocolate Syrup Swirl

Coconut Cream Pie- Coconut ice cream with graham cracker pieces

Coffee- Coffee ice cream

Coffee Toffee – Coffee ice cream with Heath Bar Bits

Country Bumpkin Pumpkin – Pumpkin ice cream with spices (fall seasonal)

Cow Jumped Over The Moon – Blue moon ice cream with pop rocks

Cranberry Walnut-Cranberry ice cream with cranberries and walnuts (fall seasonal)

Cran-Raspberry-Cran-Raspberry Ice Cream

Cream Soda- Cream Soda Ice Cream

Dark Chocolate- Dark Chocolate Ice Cream

Death By Chocolate- Dark Chocolate ice cream with white chocolate chips, chocolate flakes, and hot fudge

Dinosaur Crunch- Blue Vanilla Ice cream with Vanilla Cake Crunch

Dirt Cup-Chocolate Ice Cream with Oreos and Gummy Worms

Double Dunker-Mocha Ice Cream with Oreos and Cookie Dough

Dumpster Dive-Chocolate ice cream with brownies, Cookie Dough and Reese’s pieces

Éclair- Bavarian Cream Ice Cream with pieces of Éclairs and Chocolate Swirl

Eggnog- Eggnog ice cream (winter seasonal)

Emerald Isle- Lime, Orange Dreamsicle, and Vanilla Swirl Ice Cream

Firecracker Special- Vanilla ice cream with a blueberry and strawberry swirls and red and blue sprinkles (summer seasonal)

Fluffer Nutter- Peanut butter ice cream with a marshmallow swirl and nutter butter pieces

Four C’s- Chocolate ice cream with chocolate flakes and bordeaux cherries

French Toast your Way- French Toast Ice Cream with Chocolate Caramel Cups, Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cereal, and a Caramel Swirl

French Vanilla Cappuccino Crunch- French Vanilla Ice Cream with Cappuccino Crunch

Gateway Glacier-Chocolate malt ice cream with whoppers, dry roasted peanuts and a caramel swirl

German Chocolate Cake – German chocolate ice cream with toasted coconut and pecan pieces

Gingerbread-Gingerbread Ice Cream with Gingerbread cookie pieces

Good Ol’ Goodie- Maple Ice Cream with Milk Chocolate Flakes and Virginia Peanuts

Graham Central Station- Graham Cracker ice cream with graham cracker pieces

Go Nuts- Chocolate Ice Cream with Mixed Nuts

Grape- Grape Ice Cream (summer seasonal)

Grapefruit-Grapefruit Ice Cream (summer seasonal)

Grasshopper – Mint ice cream with Oreo cookie pieces

Gravel Road – Chocolate ice cream with a marshmallow swirl, chocolate flakes, and almonds

Green Apple- Green apple ice cream with a caramel swirl (fall seasonal)

Green Dragon- Lemon lime ice cream with sprinkles

Haystack – Coconut ice cream with a chocolate swirl and almonds

Heidi’s Holiday Mint – Mint ice cream with red and green mint pieces (winter seasonal)

Holstein – Vanilla ice cream with Oreo cookies

Honey Cinnamon-Honey cinnamon Ice Cream

Honey Wagon – Honey ice cream (made with local honey)

Hot Chocolate- Hot Chocolate Ice Cream with Mini Marshmallows (winter seasonal)

Hush Puppies- Chocolate ice cream with heath pieces, chocolate covered peanuts and Crisp Rice

In a Cloud – Cotton candy ice cream with sprinkles

Itty Bitty Pieces- Chocolate Ice Cream with a Peanut Butter Swirl and Reese’s Pieces

Jack-O-Lantern-Orange dreamsicle ice cream with a marshmallow swirl and chocolate flakes (fall seasonal)

Jalapeño- Jalapeno Ice cream

Jittery Snickers- Coffee ice cream with snickers

Kahlua Almond Fudge-Kahlua ice cream with almonds and fudge

Karen’s Crazy Cake –Yellow Cake batter ice cream with homemade cake pieces, a homemade buttercream frosting swirl and sprinkles

Kat’s Meow- Vanilla and Chocolate swirl ice cream with Kit Kats

Kelley Bear- Pink cotton candy Ice cream with gummy bears

Kelley’s Irish Cream – Irish Cream ice cream, made with Irish cream liquor

Key Lime- Key Lime ice cream with graham cracker swirl (summer seasonal)

Kiwi Strawberry – Kiwi ice cream made with fresh kiwi and a strawberry swirl (summer seasonal)

Lee’s Mint – Mint ice cream (Named after our first customer)

Lemon- Lemon ice cream (summer seasonal)

Lemon Blue- Lemon Ice Cream with a Blueberry Swirl (summer seasonal)

Lemon Meringue Pie- Lemon ice cream with graham cracker pieces and a marshmallow swirl (summer seasonal)

Leo’s Butter Pecan – Grandpa Leo’s favorite, Butter pecan ice cream with roasted and salted pecan pieces

Lets Go Cow Tipping- Mint Tippy Cow Ice cream

Lieym Bug Purple Hippo- Grape ice cream with sprinkles

Little Farmer Apple Pie-Vanilla ice cream with Little Farmer Apple Pie (fall seasonal)

Lo Carb – No Sugar Added Ice Cream- Vanilla Ice Cream

Lo Carb- No Sugar Added Ice Cream- Vanilla Chocolate Swirl- Vanilla ice cream with a sugar free chocolate syrup

ice cream flavors

Malted Oreo-Chocolate Malt with Oreos

Mango-Mango flavored ice cream (summer seasonal)

Maple Bacon- Maple (Made with real local maple syrup) ice cream with real Eden Meat Market bacon

Maple Walnut – Maple (Made with real local maple syrup) ice cream with walnut pieces

Marshmallow-Marshmallow ice cream (fall seasonal)

Merry-Go-Round- White Cake Batter ice cream with pink sprinkles and frosted pink and white animal cookies

Mexican Hot Chocolate- Chocolate Ice Cream with a Hot Pepper Punch

Midnight Milking-Chocolate ice cream with Milky Way candy bars and a caramel swirl

Milking Time-Vanilla ice cream with Milky Way candy bars and caramel

Mint Brownie- Mint ice cream with brownies and chocolate syrup

Mint Chocolate Cheesecake- Cheesecake Ice Cream with a Cream de Mint swirl and Chocolate Flakes

Mint Chocolate Chip- Mint ice cream with chocolate flakes

Mint Explosion- Mint Ice Cream with a fudge swirl, M&Ms and Oreos

Mint Marshmallow- Mint ice cream with Chocolate Syrup and Marshmallow

Mint Scout- Vanilla Ice Cream with Girl Scout Thin Mint cookies and a Creme de Mint Swirl

Molly’s Moo Mocha – Chocolate coffee ice cream

Monster Cookie- Peanut Butter ice cream with fudge and monster cookie pieces

Moo Brew- Stout Beer Ice Cream

Moo Cookie Chip –Cookie dough ice cream with chocolate flakes and cookie dough pieces

Moo Luau – Banana Split ice cream, Vanilla ice cream with strawberry, banana, pineapple with a chocolate swirl (summer seasonal)

Mrs. Chippy’s Chocolate Caramel Corn- Caramel Ice Cream with a Hard Chocolate Swirl, Chocolate Caramel Cups, and Chippy’s Chocolate Covered Caramel Corn

Mud Pie- Mocha Ice Cream with Graham Cracker pieces and a Fudge Swirl

Neon Nightcrawler-Sour Blue Raspberry Ice Cream with Sour Gummy Worms

Nerd Herd- Vanilla ice cream with Nerds

Nettie’s Nutty-Caramel ice cream with coconut, mixed nuts, and fudge

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie-Oatmeal Cookie Ice Cream with Oatmeal and Raisins

Orange Chocolate Chip- Orange ice cream with mini semi-sweet chocolate chips (fall seasonal)

Orange Dreamsicle- Orange Dreamsicle ice cream (summer seasonal)

Pack Rat- Vanilla Ice Cream with a Fudge and Caramel Swirl, Brownies, Oreos, and Cookie Dough

Pasture Pie- Dark Chocolate with a coconut swirl

Peach-Peach flavored ice cream (Summer Seasonal)

Peach Pie- Peach ice cream with peach bits and homemade pie crust pieces (summer seasonal)

Peach Praline- Peach Ice Cream with Diced Peaches and Pralines (Summer seasonal)

Peanut Butter and Jelly-Vanilla ice cream with a peanut butter swirl and a grape or raspberry or strawberry jelly swirl

Peanut Butter Explosion Cheesecake- Cheesecake Ice Cream with a Fudge swirl, Peanut Butter Cups, and Reese’s Pieces

Peanut Butter Fudge – Peanut butter ice cream with a fudge swirl

Peanut Butter Peanut Butter Cup-Peanut butter ice cream with peanut butter cups

Pecan Roll-Cinnamon Ice Cream with Pecans and a Caramel Swirl (fall seasonal)

Peppermint Bark-White Chocolate ice cream with candy cane pieces and chocolate flakes (winter Seasonal)

Peppermint Cookie- Chocolate Ice Cream with Crushed Candy Canes and Oreos (winter seasonal)

Peppy Mint- White Mint with Peppermint Patties

Pina Colada- Pina Colada Ice Cream with Pineapple and Toasted Coconut (summer seasonal)

Pineapple Coconut- Pineapple Coconut Ice Cream (summer seasonal)

Pineapple Orange- orange pineapple ice cream with bits of orange and pineapple (Summer seasonal)

Pineapple Upsidedown Cake-Pineapple Ice Cream with Pineapple Cake, Pineapple, and Maraschino Cherries

Pitchfork Pistachio – Pistachio ice cream with pistachios

Plum-Plum Ice Cream (summer seasonal)

Pomegranate- Pomegranate Ice Cream (summer seasonal)

Pralines and Cream- Vanilla Ice Cream with a Caramel Swirl and Pralines

Pucker Up!- Sour Cherry Ice Cream with Sour Patch Kids

Pumpkin Bar- Pumpkin Ice Cream with Walnuts and a Cream Cheese Swirl (fall seasonal)

Pumpkin Cheesecake- Pumpkin Cheesecake Ice cream with a Graham Cracker Swirl(fall seasonal)

Pumpkin Pecan-Pumpkin ice cream with spices and pecans (Fall seasonal)

Puppy Tracks- Vanilla Ice Cream with a Fudge and Peanut Butter Swirl and Puppy Chow

Raspberry Cheesecake – Cheesecake ice cream with raspberry and graham cracker swirl

Raspberry Chip-Raspberry Ice Cream with Chocolate Flakes

Raspberry Lemonade- Lemon ice cream with raspberry swirl (Summer seasonal)

Raspberry Pomegranate- Raspberry Pomegranate Ice Cream with a Raspberry Swirl (summer seasonal)

Raspberry Swirl-Vanilla ice cream with a raspberry swirl

Raspberry Truffle-Raspberry ice cream with a Chocolate swirl and Dark Chocolate Raspberry mini cups

Raspberry Turnover-Vanilla ice cream with Raspberry Turnovers and a Raspberry swirl

Red Raspberry – Red raspberry ice cream

Red Velvet- Red Velvet ice cream with cream cheese frosting and red velvet cake pieces

Robins Egg- Vanilla Malt Ice Cream with Colored Whopper Pieces

Root Beer- Root Beer Ice Cream (summer seasonal)

Rum Raisin- Rum ice cream with raisins (winter seasonal)

Salt Water Taffy- Salt Water Taffy Ice Cream (summer seasonal)

Salted Caramel Cashew- Salted Caramel Ice cream with a caramel swirl and cashews

Seven Layer Bar- Coconut Ice Cream with Butterscotch Chips, Graham Cracker Swirl, Toasted Coconut, Chocolate Flakes, and Walnuts

Silver Bells-Vanilla ice cream with Silver Sixlets

Slow Moving Vehicle – The Turtle, vanilla ice cream with fudge, caramel swirls with pecans

S’mores-Chocolate ice cream with marshmallow swirl, graham crackers, and Chocolate flakes

Snow Mountain Apple-Snow Mountain apple ice cream (fall Seasonal)

Speedy Turtle- Caramel Ice Cream with a Fudge Swirl and Pecans

Strawberry Angel Food-Angel food ice cream with a strawberry swirl

Strawberry Banana- Banana Ice Cream with a Strawberry Swirl (summer seasonal)

Strawberry Cheesecake- Cheesecake ice cream with strawberry and graham cracker swirl

Strawberry Daiquiri- Strawberry Daiquiri (summer seasonal)

Strawberry Fields – Strawberry ice cream with strawberry pieces

Strawberry Margarita- Tequila Margarita Ice Cream with Strawberry Flavoring (summer seasonal)

Strawberry Rhubarb Kuchen-Vanilla ice cream with homemade strawberry rhubarb kuchen pieces and a strawberry rhubarb swirl (made with local rhubarb and strawberries when available, spring/summer seasonal)

Strawberry Swirl –Vanilla ice cream with a strawberry swirl

Stuck in the Mud- Chocolate Ice Cream with Fudge and Chocolate Covered Pretzels

Stuffed Teddy-Marshmallow ice cream with a Fudge swirl and Teddy Grahams

Sugar Gem- Cookie Dough Ice Cream with sugar cookie pieces and sprinkles (winter seasonal)

Super Moo-Cherry Ice Cream, Blue Moon ice cream and Lemon ice cream swirled

Sunset- Pineapple Orange Ice cream with Raspberry Swirl (summer seasonal)

Sweet Corn-Buttered sweet corn ice cream with real sweet corn (Aug/Sept Season)

Sweet Potato Pie-Sweet potato ice cream with a marshmallow swirl (fall seasonal)

Swing Lime Sweet Cherry-it- Lime Ice Cream with a hard cherry swirl

Swinging Monkey-Banana ice cream with a peanut butter and fudge swirl

Take Away- Salted Pretzel Ice Cream with Chocolate Covered Pretzels, Virginia Peanuts and a Peanut Butter and Caramel Swirl

Tequila Margarita- Tequila Margarita Ice cream (summer seasonal)

The Marsh- Chocolate Ice Cream with Chocolate Rocks, Peanut Butter Chips, Dark Chocolate Chips, and Green Sprinkles

Three Angels- (In loving memory of Katie Berg, Sabrina Stahl, and Caitlin Scannell) Pink Cake Batter Ice Cream with Marshmallows, Marshmallow swirl, and Purple Sprinkles

Tim’s Turkey Trot- Butterscotch ice cream with mixed nuts

Tiramisu-Cappuccino Tiramisu ice cream with lady fingers, a chocolate espresso swirl and a mascarpone cheese frosting swirl and liquor

Toffee Fudge Swirl-Vanilla Ice Cream with Heath Pieces and a fudge swirl

Turkey Lurkey- Vanilla Ice cream with chocolate covered waffle cone pieces, caramel and hot fudge swirl, and Spanish peanuts

Turtle Cheesecake-Cheesecake ice cream with a caramel and hot fudge swirl and roasted and salted pecans

Twisted Cherry- Vanilla Ice Cream with a Marshmallow swirl, Chocolate Covered Pretzels, and Maraschino Cherries

Ty’s Chocolate Marshmallow-Chocolate ice cream with marshmallow swirl

Udderly Comforting Chocolate – Creamy chocolate ice cream

Vanilla Black Raspberry-Vanilla Ice Cream with a Black Raspberry Swirl

Vanilla Caramel Swirl- Vanilla Ice Cream with a Caramel Swirl

Vanilla Chocolate Chip- Vanilla Ice cream with chocolate Flakes

Vanilla Choco-Scotch-Vanilla ice cream with a chocolate and butterscotch swirl

Vanilla Fudge Ripple-Vanilla ice cream with a fudge ripple

Vanilla Snickers – Vanilla ice cream with Snickers pieces

Watermelon-Watermelon ice cream (Summer seasonal)

Wedded Bliss- Strawberry Ice Cream with strawberries and Chocolate Flakes

Wedding Cake- White Cake Batter Ice Cream with White Cake Pieces and a Raspberry Swirl

White Chocolate Raspberry – White chocolate ice cream with a raspberry swirl

Whitewash Vanilla – Premium farmstead vanilla ice cream

Wild Berry- Wild Berry Ice Cream (summer seasonal)

Wild Tart- Vanilla Ice Cream with strawberry swirl and wild berry Pop Tarts

Zebra- Vanilla Ice Cream with Devil’s Food Cake

Comments are closed.